Brought out some old chums to play one of the Warhammer Skirmish scenarios using...Age of Sigmar.
Once the situation and Gotrek and Felix stats were suitably modified it went very well.
In AoS Gotrek and Felix are not very...durable. Probably a good thing for game play but not very true to the tales of Mr. King.
Giving them the number of attacks and ward save from their WFB profiles put that to rights.
The scenario is meant to represent the climactic battle of William King's brilliant short story "Wolf Riders".
It is actually not a very accurate (!) portrayal of same.
Revealing most of the reasons would spoil the story so do find it and read it yourself.
However I can say that in the book the attack was carried out by Wolf Riders and Orcs on foot, led by a Spoiler.
The scenario as presented resulted in a fairly static game...as sieges and defending a passage can sadly.
With some tweaks it would make a great game.
As for Age of Sigmar, I am now a fan of the rules if not the setting. Even the Stormcasts have a place, to my mind, as "daemos" or "angels" for the good guys. Much prefer seeing them in a supporting role to mortal troops than as a faction on their own.
As for the rules, much simplified. The lack of a toughness score eliminates a die roll and makes every creature vulnerable to any troop type although saves play a huge part here.
Even better, one of my design goals for Warrior Heroes: Armies and Adventures in regards to organization and morale! Now, I am convinced it is simply a case of parallel development. That has happened to me too, so this is not a "they stole my idea rant". Rather its pointing out something about the the design I really like.
To wit, when morale is checked individuals may rout from the table, decreasing a unit;'s strength rather than the wholesale loss of unit morale.
What this gives is the experience of some figures running away, gradually decreasing a unit's effectiveness. Eventually one has to weigh the merits of staying and dying in place or retreating to perhaps fight again under more favorable circumstances.
Well the rules are available for free so you should try them out for yourselves if interested!
Thant's all for now.
Thanks for stopping by!